Why Does Saudi Arabia Struggle in Yemen? The War It Cannot Win and Cannot Leave

Saudi Arabia has military superiority and still cannot defeat the Houthis. Containment failed. Negotiation looks unlikely. The war has become a permanent vulnerability for the entire Gulf.

Cheap Drones vs. Billion-Dollar Hardware: The Iran-backed Houthi movement fights with guerrilla tactics, cheap suicide drones, and ballistic missiles.
Saudi Arabia is stuck in a classic asymmetric trap: it has one of the biggest military budgets on Earth, yet it cannot defeat a battle-hardened insurgent group next door—and walking away leaves its own border and economy exposed

YEET Magazine

Why Does Saudi Arabia Struggle in Yemen? The War It Cannot Win and Cannot Leave

Saudi Arabia struggles in Yemen because it is fighting a war it cannot win with tools that do not work. Its military superiority has not translated into victory. Its allies are unreliable. Its enemy is entrenched. And its options are all bad.

The military option has been tested and failed. Since the 2015 intervention, the Houthis have only grown stronger. Recent Houthi strikes on Riyadh, Abha, and Dammam airports killed dozens and injured hundreds. Saudi oil infrastructure has been attacked. The Houthis have demonstrated that they can impose costs that Saudi Arabia cannot easily absorb.

Containment has also failed. The 2022 truce reduced cross-border attacks but allowed the Houthis to consolidate territorial control and build military capacity. They used the pause to prepare for the next round, which is now underway.

Negotiation is the most favorable route on paper, but the Houthis believe they are winning. They have little incentive to compromise. And Saudi Arabia cannot outsource the conflict. The United States is focused on Iran and has limited appetite for another open-ended front. Defense arrangements with Turkey and Pakistan may strengthen deterrence but do not solve the underlying problem.

The deeper issue is that Yemen is not just Saudi Arabia's problem. It is a Gulf problem. The attacks on Saudi infrastructure demonstrate that the entire GCC is vulnerable to missiles and drones. Gulf states' economic diversification depends on secure aviation, logistics, and tourism. A war that disrupts those sectors is a war against every Gulf economy.

The solution, if there is one, requires a unified Gulf strategy and a credible political settlement between Yemenis. Neither is currently in sight. For the broader regional conflict, see will the Middle East war change everything.

What do you think? Can Saudi Arabia extricate itself from Yemen without a political settlement? Share your answer.

Sources: Chatham House; YEET Magazine